I was struck by some similarities between the conflict in Charlottesville and John Brown’s raid on Harper’s Ferry in 1859. Fanatics were the leaders in both cases, and both groups were looking for instant publicity in order to stir up a rebellion: Brown wanted the slaves to rise against their white masters, while the alt-right wants the whites to rise up and claim their putative place in the Home of the Brave. The alt-left or the antifas also want to stir up their side and confront their opponents head-on. The disciples of violence are primed and ready. More confrontations are being planned.
Watch out! These clashes will only escalate and lead to a Second Civil War, just as Harper’s Ferry led to the first one. They get everyone going, mad at the other side, spoiling for a fight. Have we learned nothing in 150 years? Even our saner leaders are not doing enough to head this off.
This is the USA. Certain things are legal: to carry guns, to march in protest, to say what you want to say in public and private forums.
we could make things illegal and safer if we wanted to by passing new laws that would forbid non-governmental marches and protests in which people are carrying weapons of any kind. We could outlaw military-style firearms period. We could censor (yes, dammit, say it proudly, censor!) certain kinds of speech as the Germans have done, in outlawing any support or symbols of the Nazi ideology. The Germans have figured out you need something called “defensive democracy” designed to keep the state safe from demagogues. German law bans the incitement of hatred or violence, or ridiculing parts of the population in a manner apt to breach the peace—including racist speech (Volksverhetzung).
This is what’s needed. So, come on, Congress! Step up to the plate and pass some laws for the greater good!
In the meantime, if you disagree with someone’s views, don’t do this:
Yell and scream at them
Throw things at them
Provoke them in any way
Do this: hold your own rally in a different spot of town or stand in silent protest with your back turned to the speakers or marchers that you disagree with. You could also try to reason with them, but Reason is in short supply these days.